Convening 2: Policy, Workforce, Integration, and Love
On February 1st-3rd, 2022, 50 Delta Center CA participants came together in community to discuss self and collective care, gain inspiration from each other and leaders in their field, and work towards system transformation. Over the first two days, participants attended three out of eight concurrent sessions of their choosing under the themes of Policy and Systems, Workforce, and Integration Implementation. Between these sessions, participants discussed and provided feedback on the State Roundtable’s action plans, as well as engaging in relationship building and unstructured dialogue. On the third day of the convening, the teams and State Roundtable each met individually to advance their project goals.
The convening began with a poignant keynote from Nkem Ndefo, founder of Lumos Transforms. Nkem focused on the collective burnout of the healthcare workforce and tools for implementing resiliency, transformation, and love in the workplace. She organized the conversation around a gardening metaphor, illuminating a hypothetical situation in which someone bought (mislabelled) sunflower seeds that ultimately grew into a pumpkin plant. She compared these seeds to healthcare’s organizational values. No matter how much attention and care (or funding) these seeds receive, if the right seeds are not sowed, they will not result in the intended outcome – you’ll never get sunflowers to grow from pumpkin seeds. “What are the seeds we are currently planting?” Nkem posed. “Hierarchy, compliance, individualism, production, disconnection.” Nkem discussed a way to dismantle some of these seeds, using a Trauma-Informed and Resilience-Oriented (TIRO) approach. The TIRO approach centers around six core values: safety, collaboration, mutuality, peer support, choice and agency, cultural humility. Then, Nkem posed one last question to the group: How would our workplaces be different if we planted love? What might it look like to incorporate all dimensions of love in the workplace, including care, commitment, trust, responsibility, respect, and knowledge?
One participant described Nkem’s session as “just the right tone and just the right timing.” This session set the stage for the rest of the convening, prompting participants to think about radical, systems-level change. Nkem’s thread of the sunflower/pumpkin metaphor continued throughout the convening, with participants being asked to reflect on a time they thought they planted hypothetical sunflower seeds and instead grew a pumpkin. Additionally, at the end of the convening, participants were prompted to reflect on self-care personally and at an organizational level.
After the keynote, participants dove into topic-specific sessions within Policy and Systems, Workforce, and Integration Implementation. While each session was designed to address participants’ specific goals and learning objectives, it is evident from reflecting on the convening that the lessons learned centered around Nkem’s six core values: safety, collaboration, mutuality, peer support, choice and agency, cultural humility.
Safety
Physical and psychological safety is a key tenant of ensuring a resilient and supported workforce. In a session titled Strategies to Support Black, Indigenous, and People of Color in Leadership Roles, participants listened to an illuminating discussion between three leaders of color in mental health: Keris Myrick, Director at the Jed Foundation and Co-Director of The Mental Health Strategic Impact Initiative; Dr. Jorge Partida, Chief of Psychology at LA County Department of Mental Health; and Jei Africa, Director of Behavioral Health and Recovery Services (BHRS) in Marin County and member of a Learning Lab Team. The panelists spoke about the need for more diverse, intersectional leaders, as well as the challenges that come from being in a leadership role. For some, speaking out against inequities or the status quo may lead to punishment, yet in other spaces, occupying a leadership position means going above and beyond the typical role and responsibility to support equity efforts and ensure that people of color feel safe and supported in the workforce. Additionally, they stressed the importance of mentorship, to develop personal relationships, mentor people of color towards professional development and leadership opportunities, and support psychological safety.
Collaboration
Collaboration is a vital factor for success in primary care and behavioral health integration. While many sessions focused on the necessity of collaboration, Brenda Goldstein, Chief of Integrated Services at Lifelong Medical Care and member of a Learning Lab Team, led an interactive discussion of the challenges organizations face when collaborating internally and externally to provide integrated care. A theme that emerged was the difficulty of sharing data between providers. One participant pointed to the lack of trust that people receiving services have for the behavioral health system that has been perceived as excessively controlling, which impacts the ability to collaborate and share data across systems.
Mutuality
Mutuality is another key tenet of primary care and behavioral health integration policy work that was discussed often at the convening. During one session, Michelle Cabrera, Executive Director at CBHDA, Linnea Koopmans, Chief Executive Officer at LHPC, and Andie Patterson, Senior Vice President of Strategy at CPCA spoke about upcoming policies of interest in California. Michelle highlighted specialty behavioral health payment and documentation reform under CalAIM, as well as DHCS’ Comprehensive Quality Strategy and the “No Wrong Door” policies, all of which would support progress towards integrated care. Andie emphasized the Comprehensive Quality Strategy as a uniquely unified vision set out by the state that puts the patient at the center of the system. Additionally, speakers discussed the role of Alternative Payment Methodology (APM) and the benefits it would bring to Federally Qualified Health Centers, in many parts because of the increased flexibility to provide integrated behavioral health services. Lastly, speakers emphasized the Enhanced Care Management (EMC) benefit of CalAIM, which will provide holistic, comprehensive services to an individual through a layered approach of primary care and behavioral health care that seeks to align payment, metrics, and care services. All of these policies depend on mutuality between primary care and behavioral health, and between payers, providers, and patients to ensure quality, integrated care.
Peer Support
Peer support and engaging people with lived experience as experts in providing care is a major topic of interest for Learning Lab and State Roundtable participants. Two convening sessions focused on the importance of peer support. First, participants heard from Jennifer Tuipulotu, Program Coordinator for the Office of Consumer Empowerment, and April Loveland, SPIRIT Peer Vocational Specialist in Contra Costa County. April and Jennifer discussed how Contra Costa is improving peer inclusion, by educating the behavioral health workforce on the role of peers, increasing the employability of peers with lived experience, and creating a culturally diverse and inclusive peer community. The purpose of this peer program is to encourage hope, resiliency, and empowerment, and to help individuals identify, develop, and sustain support systems.
Additionally, participants heard Community Medical Centers’ Chief Executive, Alfonso Apu, in conversation with James Mackey, a community health worker and clinical therapist with lived experience. Through building the Transitions Clinic Network, an evidence-based program that improves outcomes for people returning from incarceration, James and Alfonso shared how they have recruited, trained, and supported staff with lived experience. As James shared his personal story of incarceration and life with his new role, Alfonso articulated strategies Community Medical Centers has used to create an environment for James to thrive. Strategies included senior leader commitments to hiring individuals with lived experience and stigma reduction through the inclusion of staff with lived experience on medical teams.
Choice and Agency
One way that choice and agency manifest in the care system is through patients having ownership over their care, as well as providers having agency over the type and quality of care provided. Dr. Palav Babaria, Chief Quality Officer at the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), described efforts to increase this type of agency in the care system when she provided an overview of DHCS’ Comprehensive Quality Strategy. The goals of this work include engaging members as owners of their own care and defining the clinical and process outcomes that each service provider is accountable for. Additionally, Dr. Babaria talked about the role that the Medi-Cal enrollee advisory council plays in informing DHCS’ policy work. This session also included a robust discussion with questions regarding Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (SOGI) data collection challenges and lack of interoperability across electronic health records, particularly between primary care and behaviroral health. Dr. Babaria expressed interest in learning more from the Delta Center California integration and policy work as it continues to progress.
Cultural Humility
Lastly, cultural humility is an essential tenet to providing quality care, and it begins by supporting a diverse and representative workforce. A team from the Department of Counseling at San Francisco State University spoke about the importance of counselor education to create an equitable, integrated workforce. They highlighted education as a means to enact change at a policy and practice level, by serving as the pipeline to train Integrated Behavioral Health leaders. Many barriers for retaining students come from curricula that are rooted in white supremacy scholarship. Fourth year student Michael Wright shared his personal experiences as a Black man in the counseling program, and the difficulty of entering a field comprised of mostly white women. “When I first started the program, I felt I had something to prove. I knew the curriculum wouldn’t be representative or reflective of the work I would want to be doing for my community.” Now, he said the curriculum is becoming more culturally responsive through pedagogical changes, leading to more diverse student recruitment and retention.
Cultural humility can also come in the form of trauma-informed care. Dr. Ritchie Rubio from the San Francisco Department of Public Health shared strategies, tools, and resources to provide trauma-informed care in a tele-behavioral health environment. He explained six key principles of trauma-informed care: understanding trauma and stress, safety and stability, cultural humility and responsiveness, compassion and dependability, and resilience and recovery. Dr. Rubio provided a three-part tactical model for navigating how to help clients in a trauma-informed capacity. Lastly, Dr. Rubio went through various tools and technology to support trauma-informed care in a virtual setting. This includes using YouTube, iPads or audio to facilitate mindfulness practice, body scanning, and breathing training, as well as the use of art therapy, ecomaps, and virtual rooms with people as digital avatars.
For a graphic overview of each session, please see here. These visual representations elevated and connected themes from sessions in real time and contributed to participant involvement both during and after the sessions. For more of our insights and tips for running a virtual convening, please see here.
Looking Ahead
The second Delta Center CA convening offered thought-provoking insights and optimism around the future of care, as well as tangible strategies to operationalize change in participants’ organizations. When asked what they would take away from their time at the convening, participants shared, “Avenues to increase and retain diverse staff,” “Caring for the Care Workforce”, and “Trust, vulnerability, and heartwork,” among other themes. However, much of the convening content also prompted serious reflection and disappointment with the current system. One participant reflected, “Folks care about serving underserved communities, yet so many barriers to equity and diversity exist, which likely contribute to workforce morale and resignations.”
The Learning Lab Teams and State Roundtable will continue working on their projects to advance primary care and behavioral health integration through policy and practice change, centering racial equity and lived experience, with support from their coaches and the Delta Center CA Program Office. Delta Center California will continue hosting bi-monthly Virtual Learning Events, and a third and final convening in the Fall of 2022. These events will provide a venue for ongoing learning and collaboration on shared topics of interest, as well as an opportunity to build on relationships that were strengthened during this convening.
“Folks care about serving underserved communities, yet so many barriers to equity and diversity exist, which likely contribute to workforce morale and resignations.”
Participants will take with them, “Avenues to increase and retain diverse staff,” “Caring for the Care Workforce”, and “Trust, vulnerability, and heartwork.”